How To Choose a Pumpkin, According to a Pumpkin Farmer

A seasonal journey to the native pumpkin patch can embody enjoyable actions, like haunted hayrides and petting zoos. However with regards to selecting the best pumpkin to take dwelling—whether or not for cooking or displaying—confusion and anxiousness can run rampant if you do not know what you are in search of. Very like selecting a associate—or, heck, even a watermelon or avocado—with the ability to select an ideal pumpkin can get overwhelming due to all of the choices (Cinderellas! Jarrahdales! Warty Goblins!). However fortunately, there’s assist available for choosing the right one.

Natalie Andelin, farmer and co-founder of Andelin Household Farms, in Sparks, Nevada has steering to supply for a way to decide on a pumpkin, on condition that the farm grows between eight and 9 acres of pumpkins per 12 months. Under, get Andelin’s prime ideas for a way to decide on any pumpkin, whether or not you are cooking and carving it.

5 important ideas for a way to decide on a pumpkin

1. It ought to really feel heavy for its measurement

“You need it to really feel good and heavy for its measurement,” Andelin says. So, be certain to select up your pumpkin to evaluate its weight earlier than committing to at least one.

2. Be sure its stem is undamaged

“As soon as pumpkins lose their stem, they begin to deteriorate,” says Andelin. So, as you look to decide on a pumpkin, keep away from these with broken or lacking stems, and ensure to maintain the stem intact on the one you in the end choose.

“As soon as pumpkins lose their stem, they begin to deteriorate.” —Natalie Andelin, pumpkin farmer

“When the stem is pulled from the highest, you see this hole,” says Andelin. “It’s going to begin to mildew proper in that round spot the place the stem was.” Though a pumpkin can keep completely ripe for a number of weeks and even months, it received’t be lengthy earlier than it begins to get mushy if the stem is lacking.

3. Keep away from choices with indicators of frost

Andelin says sure pumpkin varieties have thicker pores and skin and may deal with a mild frost. However, she recommends in search of indicators of heavy frost publicity, which might current as a moist spot on the pumpkin’s floor. Areas that freeze throughout a frost can get broken and turn into mushy because the frozen spots thaw out.

“If we all know there’s going to be a be a tough freeze, we attempt to cowl the pumpkins with tarps and blankets,” she says, which helps preserve the frost from ruining pumpkins and creating these undesirable, spoilage-prone comfortable spots. So, when you’ve already chosen your pumpkin and are displaying it outdoors, preserve this in thoughts to elongate the squash’s wholesome lifespan.

4. Test the coloring

Be sure the pumpkin you are selecting has the suitable coloring for its selection. “If it is meant to be inexperienced, you need it to be that good inexperienced,” Andelin says. With that in thoughts, it’s useful to know what sort of pumpkin you are in search of beforehand and what it ought to appear to be.

Take a polar bear pumpkin for instance: It is meant to be as white as paper, but it may simply “sunburn” or yellow if disregarded within the solar for too lengthy. (This additionally implies that after choosing considered one of this selection, you’ll wish to preserve it in a shaded space except you don’t thoughts the colour change.)

5. Keep away from pumpkins with cuts (except it’s the look you’re going for)

In response to Andelin, pumpkins can scar over and naturally heal any gashes they get whereas rising. In truth, some growers even deliberately scar pumpkins to create distinctive designs on the floor. Nonetheless, as soon as it’s reduce from the vine, an unhealed gash will dry out and presumably contribute to molding.

The three greatest pumpkins for cooking

“You possibly can technically cook dinner down any pumpkin,” Andelin says. Nonetheless, sure sorts have thicker, darker, and richer flesh, which may be higher for baking wants. In response to Andelin, the most effective pumpkins for cooking embody sugar pie pumpkins, Cinderellas, and Jarrahdales.

Sugar pie pumpkin

Sugar pie pumpkins (or sugar pumpkin or pumpkin pie), are on the smaller aspect, at about 5 to seven kilos,” Andelin says. And to select a sugar pie pumpkin with essentially the most taste, you’ll need one which’s darker.

Along with being an amazing choice for candy dishes, sugar pie pumpkins work nice for savory eats, too. Assume: soups, roasting to function a aspect dish, and even grilling them.


For a pumpkin sweeter than the sugar pie, the yellowy-orange Cinderella pumpkin is the best way to go, as “its pulp is lighter and sweeter,” Andelin says. “This one’s actually good for pies and soups.”


“Jarrahdales are actually good ones for baking down, too,” Andelin says. “They’re a phenomenal dusty sage-green on the surface, however on the within, the flesh is orange, nearly like butternut squash.” Not solely are these visually beautiful pumpkins scrumptious, however they’re additionally great for adorning your own home.

How to decide on the most effective pumpkin for carving

Though Andelin Household Farms produces about 20 styles of pumpkins (eight to 9 of that are meant for carving), selecting the most effective for carving in the end depends on private desire. A few of the hottest choices on the farm are Cinderellas, Jarrahdales, Warty Goblins, and Midnight (that are black pumpkins); nonetheless, selecting the greatest will depend on the look that you simply’re going for, Andelin says. It doesn’t matter what, although, you’ll wish to decide an choice that feels agency and doesn’t have any comfortable spots to make sure it will final so long as potential.

Along with being agency, be certain a carving pumpkin has a sturdy backside and may rise up by itself. The very last thing you need is your delightfully spooky jack-o’-lantern spontaneously tumbling down the porch steps. You additionally may also go for a pumpkin with a flatter aspect to make for simpler carving.

One of the best ways to retailer pumpkins to elongate their lifespan

“Retailer pumpkins in a cool place, like a storage or basement, when you’re storing them extra long-term,” Andelin says. Nonetheless, when you’re trying to show your pumpkins outdoors, she recommends putting them in a shaded location or someplace away from direct daylight.

If saved in a cool, shaded space, she says that uncut pumpkins can final upwards of some months. “When you carve it, [however], it’s solely a matter of three to 5 days earlier than it begins deteriorating.”

A lot pumpkin, undecided what to make? How about this gluten-free pumpkin bread:

Spread the love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *